Exclusive New Research from the Telecom Leader

Survey stats * market share * real world deployments * and more

Now with two ways to buy…

      Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines   
   Comments

VoIP's CHOKING HAZARD

more on the topic

More Related Articles

Most parents are likely familiar with the warnings on toy labels: “Not intended for children under 3,” or “Suitable for ages 3 and up.” But what's the significance of the 3-year-old cutoff? As it turns out, substantial consumer and safety research has determined the age at which children's airways reach a size that will prevent choking. That research resulted in unambiguous regulations about warning labels.

The nascent voice-over-IP industry should be so lucky. Research on the subject of whether the VoIP industry requires regulation is nowhere near as clear as research on the correlation between choking and airway size.

In 1999, when my team formed TalkingNets, an all-IP CLEC, the regulatory issue regarding VoIP was as clear as mud. Was VoIP a value-added data service and therefore free from regulation, or was it another method for delivering voice services and therefore subject to regulation by state PUCs?

Given its recent notice of proposed rulemaking regarding VoIP, the FCC appears to have recognized that voice is now an application that can ride within an all-IP data network. What's not clear is how to apply rules and fees — created when voice was the primary service running on today's TDM network — to VoIP applications and service providers.

In order not to slow the creativity of emerging services and providers, the FCC must provide clarity in whatever rules it makes. The following points must be considered during this debate:

  • The public interest, new services, competition and choice all come first, not the interests of the incumbents.
  • Fees should not be added to VoIP just because it is voice. Fees should be collected only if traffic traverses the public network.
  • The safety of the consumer is primary, as is education.
  • Not all VoIP-based services are the same, nor are they just like primary line POTS (yet).
  • A broad user base must be supported, which means universal service and availability can't be overlooked.

During the telecom bubble of the late 1990s, investor money and regulation drove activity, and technology needed to drive advances in areas such as VoIP was not always ready. But VoIP technology is ready now. If the FCC acts to provide guidance and clarity this year, more investment will follow and consumers will be the ultimate winners. Failure to act clearly and concisely will choke the potential of VoIP.

DOSSIER TONY SURAK

Occupation: Senior director of Newforth Partners, an M&A advisory firm for technology companies; co-founder of TalkingNets

Location: Rockville, Md.

Favorite Web site: www.theonion.com

Current reading: “Right as Rain” by George P. Pelecanos

Hobbies: Golf, blues and trapping

Next Project: Building a patio on the back of my house

Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2009 Penton Media Inc.

  • Telephony Content


blog comments powered by Disqus
Get Updates Via Email
  • Telephony Content

related resources

popular articles

Webcasts

WEBCAST

Reduce Customer Churn and Cut Costs Webcast | July 22, 2009

Learn the best practices for online customer billing and service – how to implement a paperless bill, drive traffic to your web site, improve customer service.

REGISTER NOW

White Papers

WHITE PAPER

Automated End-to-End Managed Service Delivery. Sponsored by Ciena.

Ciena’s industry-leading CoreDirector Multiservice Optical Switch with FastMesh® has been used for efficient and robust core switching in the world’s largest networks. DOWNLOAD NOW

Podcasts

PODCAST

Wikimedia explores the phone as encyclopedia

Kul Wadhwa, head of business development, Wikimedia Foundation, discusses with senior editor Kevin Fitchard the Wikipedia’s future on the mobile phone. LISTEN

Blogs

BLOG

I-feature: Readers respond

As promised, a key component of Telephony’s new Interactive Featureis reader participation READ

E-Books

Telephony May Special Section: Carrier Ethernet

No slowdown in sight!

Read how carrier Ethernet is defying the slow economy. DOWNLOAD NOW!

  • Telephony Content
  • Telephony Content

commentary

Carol Wilson
Energy bill should energize change

June 29, 2009

Read Now

Carol Wilson
Steve Hilton
Ask Steve

June 29, 2009

Read Now

Steve Hilton

Recent Comments

Follow comments on Telephony

More ways to stay informed

Find us on Facebook

follow us on twitter

Browse Issues

  • June 1, 2009
  • October 1, 2008
  • April 1, 2009
  • March 1, 2009
  • February 1, 2009
  • January 1, 2009
  • December 1, 2008