Telephony University

Telephony University

Join us for an in-depth day on Deep Packet Inspection. Telephony University presents three Webcasts and an interactive panel of experts to explore all things DPI. You’ll hear from the industry professionals leading the way and participate in Q+A with our experts.

Learn more
         Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines   

Qualcomm, Nokia skirmish heats back up

more on the topic

More Related Articles

Qualcomm and Nokia are back in the courtrooms, this time in Britain, battling over the same patents the two companies failed to reach licensing agreements over last summer. The new legal action comes one week after Qualcomm won two significant victories over Nokia and chipmaker Broadcom.

Proceedings began today in the British High Court over Qualcomm’s lawsuit to bar Nokia from selling GSM/GPRS phones in the U.K. because they allegedly violate Qualcomm’s 2G technology patents. In the first stage of the proceedings, the court will decide whether the patents are valid and, if so, whether Nokia is infringing on them. The second phase would then rule on possible damages and consider the ban itself.

Qualcomm filed the complaint last year in the U.K. after filing a similar lawsuit against Nokia in U.S. District Court, but the individual suits are just spats in the overall battle between the Finnish handset maker and the CDMA chipset maker. The two have been butting heads in courts around the world and taking their cases to the U.S. International Trade Commission and the European Commission, over what is essentially Qualcomm’s core business intellectual property business model. While GSM vendors struck open licensing deals for cellular technology that ultimately dominated the global market, the same isn’t true for GSM’s flavor of 3G, wideband CDMA, which incorporates wideband CDMA technologies developed by Qualcomm. Qualcomm has been enforcing its W-CDMA patents and even those related to GSM and GPRS to the fullest extent possible. That in turn has led its competitors to exercise their own patent claims.

Qualcomm lately has been coming out on top in these global skirmishes. Last week the ITC dropped Nokia’s case against Qualcomm and ended its investigation of Qualcomm due to pending arbitration. Nokia was following Broadcom’s cue in seeking to get a ban on phones using Qualcomm’s chips because the allegedly infringed on its patents. Broadcom succeeded in pressing its case for the ban on all 3G handsets imported into the U.S.—potentially a disaster for Qualcomm—but the federal courts watered down the ban to the point it had practically no effect on Qualcomm’s shipments whatsoever.

Also, Qualcomm succeeded in getting damages in a concurrent civil lawsuit filed by Broadcom halved to $19.6 million. A federal district judge said Broadcom had not proved Qualcomm willfully infringed on its patents. Broadcom was given the option of accepting the reduced fine or re-filing the case. Broadcom chose to take its money and go home.

Though those individual cases are settled, Qualcomm and Nokia are expected to increase the pressure on one another as their unresolved licensing issues come to a head. In April, Qualcomm and Nokia’s cross-licensing deal expired, leaving the largest handset maker in the world without a royalty agreement in place. Nokia offered to pay Qualcomm $20 million to temporarily license Qualcomm technology for the quarter, but the payment was only a fraction of what Qualcomm received in royalties for Nokia handsets in the past, leading the chipmaker to reject the offer outright. Qualcomm and Nokia cut off negotiations and launched a new round of intellectual property lawsuits in the courts.

The ongoing battles, however, have begun to take their toll on Qualcomm. The cost of doing business with Qualcomm has started leading some vendors to shy away from technology Qualcomm has substantial stakes in, and the debate has started to bleed into the standards bodies. Qualcomm itself is starting to feel the financial burn of the constant litigation, estimating it will spend $200 million on legal fees in 2008.

Get Updates Via Email

related resources

popular articles

Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2008 Penton Media Inc.

White Papers

WHITE PAPER

Are You Letting Hot Prospects Go to the Competition?

You spend millions of dollars on marketing campaigns to trigger consumer interest in your services. Find out how some communications carriers are increasing conversion rates. DOWNLOAD NOW

Podcasts

PODCAST

A Telephony Podcast: Qwest Communications launched its qHome Portal

Qwest Communications launched its qHome Portal this week, uniting its Qwest Choice Home voice service and its DSL-based high-speed Internet service through Microsoft’s Windows Live LISTEN

Blogs

BLOG

Infinera: What spending slowdown?

Optical equipment vendor Infinera is apparently not seeing the same broad carrier spending slowdown related to economic uncertainty that other vendors are reporting.READ

E-Books

E-BOOK

Broadband for the Masses from Motorola

This e-book provides insights on how fixed broadband wireless services can provide affordable solutions in an unlicensed spectrum. READ NOW!

TV

TV

Interview with Jim Hansen of Embarq at NXTcomm08

Tune in to Telephony TV to watch an interview with Embarq's Jim Hansen at NXTcomm08. WATCH IT NOW.

  • Telephony Content
  • Telephony Content

current issue

Current Issue

December 1, 2008

The next network frontier offers new opportunities for service providers. Read Now

more news

Global >>

MORE

Ethernet >>

MORE

Independent >>

MORE

IPTV >>

MORE

IMS >>

MORE

WiMax >>

MORE

VOIP >>

MORE

FTTX >>

MORE

Access >>

MORE

Broadband >>

MORE

Wireless >>

MORE

Software >>

MORE

Podcasts >>

MORE

Get Updates Via Email

Browse Issues

  • December 1, 2008
  • November 1, 2008
  • October 1, 2008
  • September 1, 2008
  • July 14, 2008
  • June 30, 2008
  • Jun 16, 2008